Email security solutions protect organisations from threats that arrive by email, including phishing, business email compromise (BEC), malware, ransomware, account takeover and spoofing, and help prevent sensitive data leaving by email. Today's tools combine traditional filtering with AI that learns normal communication patterns, so they can catch convincing, text-only fraud that has no malicious link or attachment.
Email remains the most common way attacks begin, and the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center reports business email compromise losses in the billions of dollars each year. The market has consolidated too: Proofpoint completed its $1.8 billion acquisition of Hornetsecurity in December 2025. Below we compare 12 email security software options across gateway, API-based and on-premise deployment models.
Secure email gateway (SEG) | API-based (integrated cloud email security) | |
How it works | Sits in front of your mail server; MX records point to it | Connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through APIs |
Strengths | Filters before delivery; on-premise appliance options | Fast deployment; sees internal email and user behaviour; post-delivery removal |
Weaknesses | Misses internal threats; MX change needed | Usually cloud-only; acts just after delivery |
Examples | Proofpoint, Mimecast, Cisco, Fortinet, Barracuda | Abnormal, Check Point Harmony, IRONSCALES, Sublime |
Many organisations now layer an API-based tool on top of Microsoft Defender for Office 365 or a gateway.
Criterion | Weight | What we looked at |
Threat protection | 30% | Phishing, BEC, malware, account takeover, impersonation |
25% | Gateway, API or on-premise; data residency; encryption and DLP | |
Integrations | 15% | Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, SIEM, SOAR, awareness training |
Usability | 15% | False positives, admin effort, user reporting workflow |
Pricing transparency | 15% | Whether pricing is published, and how it scales |
Solution | Best for | Deployment | BEC protection | Pricing |
Proofpoint | Large enterprises with high attack volumes | Gateway (cloud or on-premise) and API | Yes | Quote |
Mimecast | Gateway plus archiving and continuity | Cloud gateway and API | Yes | Quote |
Microsoft Defender for Office 365 | Microsoft 365 organisations | Built into Microsoft 365 | Yes | Plan 1 and Plan 2 per user |
Abnormal AI | Behavioural AI against BEC | API | Yes, core strength | Quote |
Cisco Secure Email | Cisco security estates | Cloud or on-premise appliance | Yes | Quote |
Barracuda Email Protection | Mid-size organisations | Cloud gateway, API, appliance | Yes | Quote |
Check Point Harmony Email and Collaboration | Email plus collaboration apps | API | Yes | Quote |
Fortinet FortiMail | Fortinet customers and on-premise needs | Appliance, virtual or cloud | Yes | Quote |
Trend Micro Email Security (TrendAI) | Trend Vision One customers | Cloud gateway and API | Yes | Quote |
Sublime Security | Security teams wanting transparent, customisable detection | API; self-hosted option | Yes | Free tier; paid quoted |
IRONSCALES | Combining AI with crowdsourced reporting | API | Yes | Quote |
Hornetsecurity (Proofpoint) | MSPs and Microsoft 365 SMBs | Cloud | Yes | Quote |
Best for: large enterprises facing high volumes of targeted attacks.
Proofpoint is one of the leading email security vendors, protecting against phishing, BEC, malware and impersonation, with strong threat intelligence, URL and attachment sandboxing, data loss prevention, encryption and security awareness training. It offers both gateway and API-based protection, and completed its acquisition of Hornetsecurity in December 2025 to expand into the MSP and SMB market.
Key features
Deployment: cloud gateway, on-premise options and API.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: small businesses.
Best for: organisations that want email security plus archiving and continuity.
Mimecast combines a cloud email security gateway with API-based protection, email archiving, continuity during outages, DLP and awareness training, so email keeps flowing even if your mail service fails.
Key features
Deployment: cloud.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: organisations that want a single-purpose tool.
Best for: Microsoft 365 organisations wanting built-in protection.
Defender for Office 365 adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments, anti-phishing with impersonation protection, and, in Plan 2, automated investigation, attack simulation training and threat hunting on top of Exchange Online Protection.
Key features
Deployment: built into Microsoft 365.
Pricing: Plan 1 and Plan 2 are licensed per user [VERIFY current prices]; Plan 2 is included in Microsoft 365 E5.
Pros
Cons
Not for: organisations not using Microsoft 365.
Best for: organisations focused on stopping business email compromise.
Abnormal (formerly Abnormal Security) connects to Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace through APIs and uses behavioural AI to learn how each person and supplier normally communicates. It flags anomalies such as invoice fraud, vendor impersonation and compromised accounts that contain no malicious link.
Key features
Deployment: API (cloud).
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: organisations running on-premise Exchange.
Best for: organisations already invested in Cisco security.
Cisco Secure Email (formerly Cisco Email Security) provides gateway protection with Talos threat intelligence, sandboxing, encryption and DLP. It is available as a cloud service or as on-premise physical and virtual appliances.
Key features
Deployment: cloud, or on-premise physical and virtual appliances.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: small organisations.
Best for: mid-size organisations that want broad protection at a fair price.
Barracuda combines a cloud email gateway, API-based impersonation protection, incident response, archiving, backup and awareness training. Its Email Security Gateway has also been available as an on-premise appliance.
Key features
Deployment: cloud gateway, API, and appliances.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: buyers who want a single specialist tool.
Best for: organisations that want protection across email and collaboration apps.
Harmony Email and Collaboration (based on Avanan) uses APIs to protect Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace email, and also scans collaboration apps such as Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive and Slack for malicious files and links.
Key features
Deployment: API (cloud).
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: on-premise email environments.
Best for: Fortinet customers and organisations that need on-premise email security.
FortiMail provides gateway protection with antispam, antimalware, sandboxing, encryption and DLP. It runs as a hardware appliance, a virtual machine or a cloud service, and integrates with the Fortinet Security Fabric.
Key features
Deployment: appliance, virtual machine or cloud.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: cloud-only Microsoft 365 organisations wanting API tools.
Best for: organisations using Trend Vision One.
Trend Micro's email security, now under the TrendAI enterprise brand, offers gateway and API protection against phishing, BEC and malware, with sandboxing and writing-style analysis for impersonation, feeding detections into Vision One XDR.
Key features
Deployment: cloud.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: teams that want a standalone tool.
Best for: security teams that want transparent, customisable detection.
Sublime uses an open detection language, so security teams can read, write and share detection rules, combined with AI models that catch phishing and BEC. It can be deployed as SaaS or self-hosted, and offers a free tier.
Key features
Deployment: cloud or self-hosted.
Pricing: free tier available; paid plans on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: organisations without in-house security staff.
Best for: combining AI detection with crowdsourced user reports.
IRONSCALES uses AI plus a community of user reports across its customer base to detect and remove phishing, with built-in awareness training and simulation, and is popular with MSPs.
Key features
Deployment: API (cloud).
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: on-premise email environments.
Best for: MSPs and small to mid-size Microsoft 365 customers.
Hornetsecurity, acquired by Proofpoint in December 2025, offers 365 Total Protection, a suite of email security, backup, permission management and awareness training for Microsoft 365, sold mainly through MSPs. Proofpoint says it will operate as a dedicated business unit for MSPs and SMBs.
Key features
Deployment: cloud.
Pricing: on request.
Pros
Cons
Not for: large enterprises with complex needs.
Organisations that still run on-premise Exchange or other mail servers, or that must keep email processing in-country, need gateway products with on-premise or private deployment. Options include Cisco Secure Email appliances, Fortinet FortiMail, Barracuda appliances, Proofpoint on-premise deployments and self-hosted Sublime. API-based tools generally require Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace.
Email security tools reduce risk, but email itself has structural weaknesses. Anyone can send you a message, sender identities can be spoofed or closely imitated, and a single compromised mailbox exposes years of internal threads that can be forwarded anywhere.
For internal conversations about sensitive matters, such as payments, legal issues, security incidents and executive decisions, many organisations move off email entirely, onto a closed, authenticated messaging platform:
Troop Messenger is built for that model, and can run on your own servers, so internal communication never touches the public email system. For more on the options, see our guide to encrypted communication tools.
It depends on your environment. Proofpoint and Mimecast lead for large enterprises needing gateways, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 suits Microsoft 365 organisations, and Abnormal, Check Point Harmony, IRONSCALES and Sublime are strong API-based options. Cisco and Fortinet suit organisations needing on-premise appliances.
For personal use, privacy-focused providers such as Proton Mail and Tuta offer end-to-end encryption. For organisations, the better approach is usually to secure the business email platform with strong authentication and email security tools, and to move sensitive internal discussions to a closed, encrypted messaging platform.
The most widely used providers, such as Microsoft 365 and Gmail, see the most attacks simply because of their size, not necessarily because they are less secure. Most breaches result from phishing, weak passwords or missing multi-factor authentication rather than flaws in the provider itself.
A secure email gateway is a service or appliance that sits between the internet and your mail server, inspecting incoming and outgoing email for spam, phishing, malware and data leaks before it is delivered. Organisations point their MX records to the gateway so all mail passes through it.
Microsoft 365 includes Exchange Online Protection, and Defender for Office 365 adds stronger protection. Many organisations find this sufficient, while others add an API-based or gateway product to catch more business email compromise and targeted phishing, depending on their risk and the threats they face.
